It was close call. I think Jay looks lot more bigger than phil health and came in bit more leaner than Phil. Jay weighs 270 and Phil weighs 216 and they are both the same height!! If those numbers are true, that is just incredible. But Phil definitely improved a lot from last year.
I don’t know why they keep on changing the camera angle whenever there is possible comparison shot between Jay and phil. And maybe they just gave it to Jay because they know Phil will be dominating this for the next few years to come.