Exercise Biology - The Science of Exercise,  Nutrition & building muscle

Main Menu

Scans for Low Back Pain: Good or Bad

April 19 2011

This was a really interesting post by Neil O’Connell at bodyinmind.org.This is such a relevant post because almost all of us will have some sort of low back pain in our life.

We now clearly know that abnormal findings on the x-ray and MRI ( like disc herniations, bulging disk, degenerating joints and so on) are clearly NOT related to the onset, severity, prognosis, or duration of low back pain.

image

This is now so well established that the American College of Physicians have come forward with clinical guidelines saying” Clinicians should not routinely obtain imaging or other diagnostic tests in patients with nonspecific low back pain

Non-Specific low back pain is defined as low back pain that cannot reliably be attributed to a specific disease or spinal abnormality. 85% of the low back pain is due to non specific effects.

Imaging is only recommended for a minority of people whose low back pain can be attributed to specific pathology like cancer, compression fracture, spinal infection, cauda equina syndrome. progressive n neurological deficits and such.

Though these guidelines exist, physicians routinely get scans for patients. But the question is there any harm? The answer is YES.

I am not going though the design specifics of the study. You can check the link for more info.

  • The results showed that no-MRI groups came off disability around 200%  faster than the low-propensity early MRI subgroup!
  • Medical costs were also dramatically different and in the same direction.
  • The risk of having surgery for the no-MRI groups was reduced to 3% and 10% in comparison with the early MRI group (100%).

This post again emphasizes the powerful role of the psycho-social factors in pain which are still missing in our thinking about pain.

The Llnk to the post: http://bodyinmind.org/spinal-mri-and-back-pain/

If you like it, please share it:

Related Articles

verim | Sun February 09, 2014  

So, how can someone treat low back injuries without diagnostics? Reading mind waves? I had severe low back pain, visited several chiropractors and physiother… They began to treat my herniated disc, it was diagnosed by simptoms only, without screening. For 6 months, it costs lot of money… Without result. After that, I begin to think about surgery, and ask a more clever specialist for opinion, who thought that proper diagnostic is the first step. MR show spondylolisthesis grade 2, and spondilolisis, etc… If my first doctor would think like that, before 6 months, probably I should stay at spondylolisthesis grade 1… So, my experience is, if you are not doing the right diagnostics, probably you continue ruining your health with inadequate treament and loosing time. If this is ok to you, be my guest smile)

What do you think?

Smileys

NAME

EMAIL *email will never be displayed

URL (optional)

Please answer the question below:

what is the color of sky

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

>